U2 – CARNAVAL DE LUZ: REVIEW

U2
Carnaval De Luz (Island)
WHAT WE TALK ABOUT when we talk about a great band with a long and mixed – because perfection is impossible and consistency unlikely, for us as much as them –history: what we want it to be, what we want to see. Oh, and cricket.
I suspect Edge, Bono, Adam Clayton and Larry Mullen Jr, who I am sure are close followers of the Ireland cricket team, had not factored this into their release schedule as choosing to set Carnaval De Luz loose between the South African tour and the visit of New Zealand must have seemed smart only months ago. But a new U2 album arriving in the middle of a “scandal” in Australian cricket is instructive.
For those not as plugged into cricket as U2, in this rehashed sporting story a new book from a recently retired player asserts a view on the thinking and behaviour of his teammates almost a decade ago, backed by a few similarly no-longer playing members; a current player, captain now but back then a relatively junior member of the team, disputes this characterisation; many days of pontificating ensues.
In the media, much more than in the wider public who pretty much had enough of this almost a decade ago, arguments rage over who to believe and how much stock to place in each side of the argument. The bloc which argues everyone’s a crook so hang them all and start again says “see, told you”; the bloc which doesn’t trust the brown lot with funny prayers anywhere says “he just wants to sell books, and he’s not one of us”; the bloc which sees skulduggery everywhere says captain is “a mouthpiece” for the establishment; the bloc inclined to see good in the captain and the ex-player fall into a “there’s truth in each camp and we’ll never know to what degree” hole of good intentions.
The judgement and verdict? The details are contestable, interpretable, and wherever you started is probably where you finished because, in truth, that’s probably where you wanted to be. Which brings us back to U2.
Since the turn of the century, a point now roughly halfway through a career begun at a Dublin school in the wake of punk, each new U2 album has been cursed or claimed by the band, their boosters and their haters as “a return”. A return to their roots or a return to their heyday, a return to their adventurism or a return to their conservatism, a return to their status or a return to their irrelevance. As with the cricket business, many of these claims have been the foundation of stories/reviews with agendas that pre-date or exist separately from the actual music. ‘Twas ever so; will ever be.
So if you’ve been reading the slew of reviews accompanying Carnaval De Luz – which translates on the Iberian Peninsula as carnival of light, a sensible appropriation rather than another gleeful mixed-translation like Bono’s “uno, dos, tres, catorce” at the start of Vertigo – the hard to miss point repeated is this is, yes, a return. Which is, we’re mostly told, a good thing, on the assumption you’d not be reading about them if you weren’t of the view that at some point(s) in the past, U2 were the dog’s bollocks.
In Street Of Dreams this back-to-the-future is a return to gospel-tinged grandeur with Edge guitar in late ‘80s mode and Mullen’s drums militarily pushing the movement, while in Silencio the guitars are rougher, maybe Boy/October-ish, with a bit of Rattle And Hum swagger. If The Greatest Show On Earth begins with a sense they have found what they’re looking for and it’s I Still Haven’t Found What I’m Looking For, the Irishmen don’t disabuse you of that notion at any point in its five minutes and 34 seconds, even if they choose not to soar with eyes to heaven as they once did reflexively.
While The Mirror Maker (Rosalia) looks to and celebrates the wilfully OTT Spanish artist Rosalia, its form leans into the more simplistic “we’re back as a rock band not an art group” thrust of the turn of this century. But then La Reina, which translates as the queen if you’re living on that ol Iberia, is the most traditional piece of rock across these 12 songs, and makes The Mirror Maker look sorta kinda Rosalia-ish by comparison.
For anyone hankering for a bit of tech-meets-techno, wraparound sunnies-meets-irony U2, the opening track Go (Carnaval De Luz) is twitchy, keyboard-y, Eno-y (Brian is indeed involved) and more a palate cleanser than a whole track, but the seemingly regulation moody rock of Can’t Stop Us Now and the burbling substrata of Torn (an unlikely and perhaps not surprisingly poignant duet with the clearly vulnerable Dolly Parton), are more decided nods to the principles if not always the sound of Zooropa/Pop period U2.
There’s probably no way to listen to this album as a cleanskin, without your long-established position on U2 – from when in particular they were good and why, to whether they were ever actually any good – clouding your judgement. And that is especially true when If The World Is At War We Better Not Be, set in that Dublin school just before inchoate teenage wish latched on to the romantic collective will of four boys, opens with the none-more-Bono couplet of “No such thing as rock and roll, we just needed it to be/I was standing in the schoolyard waiting for you to happen to me”.
Maybe Springsteen is the only other singer who could get away with that. And maybe not even him, or them. Come on, it is high cheese, and I like cheese.
But as with so much of this album, which – and stop me if you think that you’ve heard this one before – to my ears is solidly consistent, above average quality, while not ever tipping into excellence, how much you tolerate or celebrate that gets down to your predilections or prejudices rather than whatever passes for objectivity. As with a certain cricket contretemps, we’re too far gone into the weeds here to really see beyond a “truth”. Choose your side.
READ MORE
HEAR MORE
SPOTIFY: Listen to U2 – Carnaval De Luz
APPLE MUSIC: Listen to U2 – Carnaval De Luz




Comments